10 Reasons The Ipad is Overrated

IPad has been met with much hype but not enough type about its functional benefits.

On April 3, 2010 the iPad was finally released in the United States. However, unlike past anticipated launches of the iPod Touch and iPhone, there is as much skepticism as there is excitement surrounding the iPad. In an online poll of over 1,300 people, 58% of respondents said that they will not an iPad while 25% will have to think about it. The early reports are in and the verdict: The iPad is nothing special if not a waste of money versus a netbook.

Here are just 10 of the reasons why:

10 ) Minimal selection of external ports
The available connections are the dock connector and a 3.5 mm headphone jack. There are built in speakers and a microphone but no separate jacks to plug in your own. Even USB (remember the “U” stands for universal) cables need a $30 adapter to connect to the iPad. This this is supposed to be a cross between a smartphone and a netbook but has less connection capabilities than an iPod.

9) Bluetooth Headset Required to Make Calls
The iPad itself cannot make or receive external calls. However, users can still make calls by downloading a VOIP application and using it over a wireless network or 3G. Bluetooth headsets either look geeky or douchy on people and would totally not look cool for Apple users. Furthermore, there are the many limitations of VOIP compared to cell phones

8) iBookstore Only in the United States
Despite being available in Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Spain, Switzerland and the UK the iBookstore will only be available in the United States for the time being. Although there may be extra legal complications involved with expanding the iBookstore globally Apple is alienating their global markets by providing a limited product. Some could consider it discriminatory pricing as the price points are generally the same worldwide but the products differ slightly. The iBookstore is supposed to be the literary version of iTunes – a major factor in the iPod’s success and a primary function of the iPad is to read e-books.

7) Can Only Download Software from the Apple Store
How can the iPad be a cross between the smartphones and laptops when it can not even download and run third-party software. The Apple App Store has been notorious for banning popular applications such as Google Voice. iPad users can not even change the default browser. The lack of this functionality makes the iPad too much like the iPhone and less like an Asus Eee.

6) Battery Policy
Like iPods and iPhones, the iPad’s lithium-ion polymer battery loses capacity with each successive charge. However, unlike iPods and iPhones the iPad’s battery cannot be replaced when it is dead. Instead, Apple while replace your entire iPad with a new one for a charge of US$99. This is a killer for the underground economy of stores that replaced Apple batteries for cheap prices. Furthermore, some people may develop a sentimental attachment to their iPads – some may even personalize their iPads by giving them names – and would not accept to replace their iPad let alone pay $99 for it.

5) No Camera
How hard is it to put a camera on the top? Having a camera function turns the iPad in the essential item to take everywhere you go. Currently that position is taken by cell/smart phones which is win because they are smaller and more focused on communication. The iPad would have been perfect for video chat as you could have held the iPad right in front of you and feel like you are face to face with the person you are video chatting with. The lack of camera only magnifies the iPad’s inability to emulate a computer’s creative capabilities.

4) No Widescreen
The screen display is no doubt beautiful and a attractive feature which is disappointing to hear that there is no16:9 widescreen aspect ratio on the iPad. In an era where practically everyone owns a LCD or flatscreen monitor or television, the iPad will look like the old, clunky 4:3 TVs again. Watching movies on the iPad should be an enjoyable experience however the improved comfort may not be worth the video quality trade-off.

3) No Flash Support
Flash is integral to so much that is currently on the Internet and many computer users know that Flash support is usually one of the first add-ins the get with a new browser. The iTouch and iPhone did not have flash support either but they were a music device and smartphone respectively and were not positioning themselves as a competitor with netbooks. Although sites like Youtube have become less dependent on Flash and can be viewed without Flash support, the iPad will still provide an inferior web experience.

2) No Multitasking
For a company that is so beloved by the youth population they sure do not know a low about their target market. Generations that have grown up with the technology of the late 1990s and early 2000s are ADHD-freaks whose focus darts between hundreds of things a second. We need to listen to music while we read e-books and to to surf the net while working on a word document. Most people know what Alt-Tab does because it is so vital to their multitasking usage. Having no equivalent “Alt-Tab” on the iPad is silly and should be frustrating for many young users.

1) Not Sexy Enough
Is the iPad really a mobile device? With a 9.7 inch LED display, the iPad is hardly a device that you can keep in your pockets or purse. Then again, the iPad does not have the same design genius of the iPod and iPhone and does not necessarily scream cool. There has been much ado about the fat bezel that surrounds the touchscreen. Combine these physical imperfections with the lack of widescreen, flash support, and no camera and the iPad is no longer a must-have, mass-market product and more of a niche for early technology adapters.

In other words, the iPad will not become the cultural symbol the that iPod and iPhone have become because it is simply not cool enough nor useful enough. This plagued another Apple product – the Macbook Air – which turned out to be mostly hot air when consumers realized that it was a $2,000 paperweight of a computer. The iPad may just be the victim of intense expectations. I am still confident that Apple can be the company that brings tablets and touch-screen technology into the mainstream but sadly, their first iPad is only a small step in the right direction.

When the IPad first came I thought to myself “Big Deal, it’s just an IPod but a brick version, the people who would make the most out of it are elderly people who need larger writing to read…”

Great article and good points.

Aries Perez
10.04.06

After a year, I wish the writer of this article would care to check if everything written he, especially the “last” part, still holds true. Apple has taken the world with its iPad by storm; they literally “created” another device category; the table pcs or the post-pc devices. With millions of units sold despite criticisms, no one can deny that it has become an eon defining icon in the tech world that other companies eventually “flummoxed” and ended up as “copy cats” aftr iPad. Now, i’m writing this on my iPad 2. With a whopping 450,000 + apps, iPad is certainly the king of tablet pcs in terms of functionality, ease of use, and security. Despite its apparent “confining” environment, compared to other windows and android devices, IT IS STABLE AND HARDLY VIRUS INFLICTED. If you are to choose between the “extra” features that are just quantitative in nature and the functionality that iPad and now, iPad 2, deliver, which is quality wise, the best, as a buyer, I wouldn’t settle for any of those.

Besides, you don’t buy the iPad for what it is not…
You buy it for the MAGICAL things that it does.
And by saying “magical,” I literally mean it. Go and have one to see for yourself.

John
10.04.06

@Perez:

The Ipad is overrated. Nuff Said. The people that buy the Ipad are doing it for the status, as with most Apple products. The only Apple product, in my eyes – if you aren’t editing film or mixing music, that lives up to its name and doesn’t break the bank is Ipod (which is an MP3 player in it of itself). That thing was made to do one thing and it does is specular: play music.

matt
10.04.06

whaaat? this year?

comments powered by Disqus
Loading